Coffee Percolator Vs Moka Pot: Which one brews the best coffee?
Are you a true coffee lover? Do you love the aroma of freshly brewed coffee filling up your house? Well, then you’re in the right place because today we’re going to talk about the battle between the coffee percolator and the Moka pot.
I have to admit, I’m a bit biased towards the Moka pot. There’s something romantic about the idea of making coffee like the Italians do – strong and bold, just like their personalities.
But, I’m willing to put my personal preferences aside and give both brewing methods a fair chance.
If you’re a beginner or an expert in coffee brewing, this guide provides all the essential information for making a delicious cup of coffee at home.
Within each product, I’ll be taking a closer look at the key differences of:
- Taste
- Brew Process
- Capacity
- Cost
- Ease of Use
- And much more!
Only after a specific section of the Coffee Percolator and Moka pot comparison? Jump around using the links above to find what you need.
Ready for the battle of the two best coffee pots?
Let’s get into it!
These opinions are my own. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means that if you click on link and make a purchase, I may earn a commission. This does not affect the price you pay for any product or service. I only recommend products that I believe are of high quality and value, and that I believe will be helpful or relevant to my readers.
Product Overview
Before we get into the review, let me give you a bird’s-eye view of both the Coffee Percolator and the Moka pot.
First, if you’ve had the chance to experiment with coffee makers, you may have found that have a little bit of a learning curve.
Before we dive into my product review, if you’re not sure if a Moka pot is what you need right now – or you want an in-depth look at how they work and what you can do with them – I cover all of that and more in this post: Moka Pot, how to brew the prefect cup of coffee.
When it comes to coffee, I take my brew seriously. I’ve tried just about every method out there – from French press to pour-over to cold brew. But two methods that always seem to cause a bit of a debate are the Coffee Percolator and the Moka pot.
Let’s start with the Coffee Percolator. This classic method involves boiling water that gets forced through coffee grounds and into the top chamber. The result is a bold, strong cup of coffee with a bit of a kick. It’s the coffee that fuels you up for a long day and won’t let you down.
On the other hand, we have the Moka pot – an Italian invention that has been around for almost a century. This method uses steam pressure to extract the coffee oils from the grounds, resulting in a rich and flavorful cup of coffee. It’s perfect for when you want something with a bit more depth and complexity.
So which one do I prefer? Honestly, it depends on my mood. Some mornings, all I need is the jolt of energy that the Coffee Percolator provides. But on lazy afternoons, I love to make a cup with my Moka pot and savor the complex flavors.
Both coffee brewing methods have their pros and cons. It all comes down to personal preference – so go ahead, try them both out and see which one fits your tastes best. And hey, if you’re feeling adventurous, why not try mixing the two methods together? Who knows, you might just discover your new favorite brew.
Let’s Compare, One Coffee Maker Feature at a Time
By the end of this article, you’ll know so much about coffee makers that you’ll be ready to make a choice and probably be ready to host your own get together.
What method has the better coffee taste?
For most coffee aficionados, the most important feature in a coffee brewing method is the taste. What’s the point of making coffee if it doesn’t taste good?
When it comes to comparing the coffee percolator and the Moka pot, it’s all about flavor.
The percolator is a classic choice for coffee lovers, and for good reason. It brews coffee using boiling water and steam, which results in a strong, full-bodied flavor. Plus, the sound of the percolator brewing is like music to our ears. It’s like the coffee machine version of a comforting, familiar song.
The Moka pot has been gaining popularity amongst coffee loves in recent years. And for good reason.
The Moka pot uses pressure to brew the coffee, which results in a rich, flavorful shot of espresso-like coffee.
What I love about the Moka pot is this espresso style coffee can be used to make a cafe mocha, latte and anything else you can make at a coffee shop.
Plus, it’s compact and perfect for those that live in smaller spaces or are always on-the-go.
Who’s the winner?
Honestly, there is no winner on this one. Both deliver a great product, but it’s two completely different products.
Are you looking for a cup of coffee? Or did you want a strong coffee or espresso?
How does the brew process differ between the Coffee Percolator and the Moka pot?
Ah, you’ve made it to the coffee talk. This is where things get serious – or should I say, caffeinated. Let’s chat about the brewing process differences between a Coffee Percolator and a Moka pot.
First things first, let me introduce you to these two coffee brewing beauties.
A Coffee Percolator is a classic coffee maker that has been around for ages. It features a chamber at the bottom to hold water, a vertical tube that reaches up to the top of the percolator, and a basket that holds the coffee grounds.
When the water boils, it is forced up the tube and seeps through the coffee grounds, dripping back down into the chamber below.
Electric percolators are perfect for delicious coffee. You can pop it on without turning on the stove.
On the other side of the coffee spectrum, we have the Moka pot. This little Italian wonder is a stovetop coffee maker that uses steam pressure to brew your coffee. It consists of a lower chamber for water, a filter basket for coffee grounds, and a upper chamber to collect the brewed coffee.
Pretty much fool proof without worry about when its done. Just make sure to throw your heat source on medium for a perfect Moka pot coffee.
Now, the brew process between these two is quite different. While a Coffee Percolator uses a constant boiling and re-brewing method, the Moka pot relies on steam pressure to push the hot water through the coffee grounds. This results in a stronger and more concentrated coffee compared to the milder brew you’ll get with a percolator.
Who’s the winner?
But hey, coffee is a personal preference, and both methods have their own unique charm. Some people swear by the rich taste of Moka pot brews, while others enjoy the familiarity of a classic percolator. I’m in the Moka pot camp for sure.
So, whether you’re a percolator person or a Moka pot enthusiast, one thing is for sure – you need a good cup of coffee to start your day. And lucky for you, we’ve got just the thing to quench your coffee cravings.
Which has a bigger capacity? The Coffee Percolator vs the Moka pot
When it comes to the capacity of the Coffee Percolator vs the Moka pot., the winner is clear.
The must-have feature in my book is capacity. As someone who drinks coffee like it’s water, I need a coffee maker that can keep up with my caffeine addiction. And that means I need a large capacity.
While both the Coffee Percolator and the Moka pot have their merits, when it comes to capacity, the Coffee Percolator wins hands down.
With a larger size and the ability to make large batches of coffee for a crowd of people, this machine is perfect for dinner parties or family gatherings.
But don’t discount the Stainless Steel Moka pot just yet. The main difference is the Moka pot is giving you an espresso coffee. It needs the high pressure to brew effectivly.
Its smaller size and portability make it a great option for solo coffee drinkers who want that strong, espresso-like taste without the hassle of a full-sized espresso machine.
Who’s the winner?
So if you’re a coffee fiend like me who needs a large capacity machine, go for the Coffee Percolator. But if you’re looking for something more manageable, the Moka pot is the way to go. Either way, you can’t go wrong with these classic coffee makers.
Which Coffee Maker is Cheaper: A Coffee Percolator or a Moka Pot
All the features in the world mean very little if you can’t afford them.
When it comes to making coffee at home, there are so many options to choose from. From French presses to espresso machines, the possibilities are endless. But if you’re on a tight budget, the two contenders that come to mind are the coffee percolator and Moka pot.
So, which one is cheaper? The coffee percolator wins this round, coming in at around $20-$30. The Moka pot, on the other hand, can range from $25 to $50 depending on the size and brand. However, keep in mind that the Moka pot can also replace your need for an expensive espresso machine in the long run.
Who’s the winner?
The choice between a coffee percolator and Moka pot really comes down to personal preference and your budget. If you’re a fan of strong, bold coffee and want to save a few bucks, go for the coffee percolator. If you want to indulge in an espresso-like coffee and don’t mind spending a little more, go for the Moka pot.
No matter which one you choose, both the coffee percolator and Moka pot will make your mornings a little brighter and your wallet a little happier. Happy brewing!
Ease of Use: Coffee Percolator vs. Moka Pot
When it comes to getting my daily caffeine fix, I am all about simplicity and ease of use. And that’s why I’ve tried both the coffee percolator and the Moka pot to see which works best.
Let’s start with the coffee percolator. This traditional brewing method involves boiling water and passing it through some ground coffee (usually placed in a basket) until the desired strength is achieved. Throw whatever grind coffee beans in, including fine grind. Simple, right?
Well, not if you’re like me and get distracted easily.
I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve forgotten about my percolator, only to have it boil over and create a mess on my stove. Plus, cleaning the basket and the tube can be a bit of a hassle.
Now, let’s talk about the Moka pot. This Italian invention is a stovetop espresso maker that uses steam pressure to push boiling water through courser grind coffee. Finer grind my slip right through.
The resulting brew is rich coffee, with a distinctive flavor that’s perfect for espresso lovers. And the best part? It’s virtually foolproof. I can make a perfect cup of Moka coffee even when I’m still half asleep in the morning.
Who’s the winner?
All in all, both the coffee percolator and the Moka pot are easy to use as long as you pay attention to what you’re doing. But for me, the Moka pot wins hands down. It’s sleek, versatile, and makes a delicious cup of coffee every time. Plus, it’s a great conversation starter when I have friends over for brunch!
Which Coffee maker is better: Coffee Percolator or a Moka Pot?
By this point, you may already know that I prefer the Moka Pot. It’s true! I believe it provides a superior product with more versatility.
However, if you have a larger group, the Moka Pot just doesn’t cut it. Even with the bigger pots. A Percolator Coffee is the way to go.
While some of it is about personal preference, you also have to take into consideration the taste differences.
If you need some more information on different Moka pots, make sure to check out my full guide. Or if you are ready to pull the trigger, you can pick one up here.
If you want to know more about the Moka pot, we have a whole series on its features, brewing tips and even some recipes. Click here to read more.
As far as Coffee Percolators go, there is only one brand I trust. The Presto Electric Coffee Percolator.